The Employee vs. Business Owner Tax Comparison

If you've ever wondered about the nitty-gritty details of self-employment taxes, you're not alone. Transitioning from being an employee to becoming a business owner or an independent contractor can be a complex journey, especially when it comes to understanding your tax obligations. To demystify the world of self-employment taxes, let's take a closer look at how they differ from the taxes you paid as an employee. 

Firstly, let me introduce myself. I am  Faisal Khan, a Tax accountant specializing in helping real estate professionals, small business owners and independent contractors save a bundle on their taxes. But today, this Blog is for everyone, whether you're a business owner or not.


Employee Tax Responsibilities

As an employee, your paycheck likely seemed straightforward. You received your gross wages, but unbeknownst to you, several deductions were already made, such as:

While these deductions were taken directly from your paycheck, there's another crucial aspect you might not have been aware of – your employer was also making tax deposits on your behalf:

When combined, both your contributions and your employer's contributions added up to 15.3%.

Business Owner or Independent Contractor Tax Responsibilities

Now, let's shift to the world of self-employment taxes. This comparison is relevant not only to traditional business owners but also to independent contractors, such as realtors, Uber drivers, or physicians who operate independently.

As a self-employed individual, your tax journey is different. You don't have taxes withheld from your income, but rather, you are responsible for paying them on your own. Here's the breakdown:

It's essential to understand that when you become self-employed, you wear two hats – the employer and the employee. You are now responsible for both the green and blue portions of FICA taxes, totaling 15.3% of your profit.

In addition to self-employment taxes, you also have to consider federal and state income taxes. These taxes are calculated based on your income, and the rates vary depending on your tax bracket and your state's tax laws.

The Pay-As-You-Go System

An essential concept to grasp is that the U.S. tax system operates on a pay-as-you-go basis. As an employee, your employer withheld taxes from your paycheck and remitted them to the IRS on your behalf. In contrast, as a business owner or independent contractor, no one does this for you.

You are required to send your self-employment and income taxes to both federal and state authorities quarterly. Failing to make these quarterly payments can result in penalties. While these penalties might seem daunting, they are typically not as high as you might imagine, so don't let that stress you out.

A Note on the Social Security Portion

The Social Security portion of the FICA tax only applies to your first approximately $135,000 of income. After reaching this threshold, you are no longer required to pay the Social Security tax (6.2%), but you must continue to pay the Medicare tax (1.45%).

In conclusion, understanding self-employment taxes is crucial for anyone venturing into entrepreneurship or working as an independent contractor. You are now both the employer and the employee, responsible for remitting your taxes, and it's essential to stay on top of your quarterly payments to avoid penalties. Keep these differences in mind as you navigate your self-employment journey, and consider consulting a tax professional for personalized guidance. If you found this information helpful, don't forget to like and subscribe for more insights, or feel free to reach out with any questions.